Skip to content

Playbooks

Why you can rank on Google and still be missing from ChatGPT's answer

Godfrey, lessClick

A software company can rank well on Google and still be missing from ChatGPT’s answer because the two are decided in different ways. A ranking is a position in a list of links. An AI answer is a short list of names, written from a handful of pages the assistant reads, and many of those pages are not yours.

How is an AI answer different from a search result?

A search result gives the buyer ten links and leaves the choosing to them. An AI answer does the choosing. The buyer asks which tool to use, and the assistant replies with three or four names and a reason for each.

That changes what it means to be visible. On a results page, position seven still gets seen. In an AI answer, there is no position seven. A company is either one of the few names or it is absent.

Where does an assistant get its names from?

An assistant draws on two things: what it learned during training, and what it finds when it searches the web for the question. When it searches, it reads a small number of pages and writes the answer from them.

The pages it reads are often not vendor homepages. For a “best tool for” question, the pages that answer most directly are comparison articles, review sites, directories and lists. If those pages name your competitors and not you, the assistant has little reason to name you either.

Why do third-party pages matter so much?

Third-party pages matter because they are where the comparison already happens. A buyer question such as “best contract software for a 40-person company” is a comparison question. The page that best answers it is a comparison page, and the assistant is likely to lean on it.

Three kinds of third-party page tend to come up:

  1. Comparison and “best of” articles that list several products for a category or use case.
  2. Review sites and directories where buyers rate and filter products.
  3. Discussion threads and community answers where people recommend tools to each other.

Your own pages still count. They are where an assistant checks what your product does, who it is for and what it costs. But your own site rarely decides on its own whether you make the list.

What on your own pages helps?

Pages that answer buyer questions plainly help most. An assistant looking for “contract software for a 40-person company” is helped by a page that says, in its first lines, that the product is contract software built for companies of that size.

Four things are worth checking on your key pages:

  • A plain statement of what the product is and who it is for, near the top, in the buyer’s words rather than a tagline.
  • Pricing and plan details in text, not only in an image or behind a form.
  • Comparison pages that say honestly how you differ from the names buyers compare you with.
  • Content that reads without JavaScript, because some crawlers do not run it.

What should you do first?

Find the questions where you are missing and look at what the answer cites. The sources tell you where the decision is being made. Sometimes the fix is a clearer page on your own site. More often it is a comparison article that has never heard of you, or a directory listing with old facts.

lessClick’s Foundation package starts there: a benchmark of about 30 buyer questions, the sources each answer cites, and the pages worth fixing first.